10 Easy Homemade Treats Your Cat (And Instagram!) Will ... Cowboy Way’s feline taste-testers approved of these cheesy, gooey treats made from a combination of cheese, yogurt, flour, cornmeal and water.Flatten the mixture out with a rolling pin and bake like a pizza for 25 minutes, then cut into tiny, cat-friendly squares. If the finished product is firm on the outside and chewy on the inside, you’ve baked yourself some serious bargaining power.